Cedar Hill Golf Course History
2012 Marks Bill Irvine's 64th Year Using
CHGC
The pages associated with this site are in no way officially connected
to
Cedar Hill Golf Course nor Saanich Municipality.
"Hey, Billy, do you want to come golfing with us at Cedar Hill Golf
links?"
What a strange question to ask Billy Irvine: he'd never golfed before nor had he
ever thought about golfing.
"Sure, let's go." replied Billy.
"Do you guys have any clubs?" Billy enquired.
Seemed like a reasonable question to ask if four lads were going to golf the
nine-hole course that doubled as a cow pasture.
"Ya, Tom's got some, we can all use them."
That was Bill Barker's response and for sure, Bill always had all the answers.
So, Bill Barker, Tom Hardy, Buddy Wells and Billy Irvine set out from where
they met at the corner of Doncaster and Edgeware Streets to walk the
one-kilometer
over to the clubhouse at 1468 Finlayson Road in Victoria, British Columbia. This
was the summer of 1948.
Now, the boys had heard all about 'Old Man Young'. Harry Warren Young was the
operator and lessee of the golf-course that had been carved into McCrae's Farm
way back in 1921. The four boys were not aware of all the details but they had
heard that 'the Old Man' did not like kids and would just as soon kick them off
the course as sell them a green-fee. Needless to say, the pre-teens were on
their best behavior upon entering the clubhouse to meet Mr. Young and pay out
their hard-earned money.
"Is that all the clubs you have between you?" asked the Old Man.
"Yes, sir," the well-behaved boys answered almost in unison.
"Well, I'll let you out but don't you hold anyone up and I want each of you
to have a club in your hand at all times." said the Boss man.
As soon as the boys paid up their fifty-cents each, they headed for the
first-tee box and each took a club from the assortment. Bill Barker kept the
extra two clubs plus the putter. Billy took the brassy, Tom the four iron and
Buddy claimed the five iron.
The tee-box was situated under a great Oak tree and was arrived at by walking
through the parking to the left of the clubhouse. Actually, 'clubhouse' is a
misnomer. The 'clubhouse' was nothing more than the basement of a regular
dwelling and the entrance was the backdoor to the basement. Green-fees and balls
were purchased over the counter which was setup on the left-hand side after
entering.
Bill was first to hit. Each boy in turn either used the driver Bill had or
borrowed the brassy from Billy. The first hole was a par four and if one could
catch the hill running the full length down the left-hand side of the fairway, a
good run could be expected to carry the ball all the way down to the gully which
cut across the fairway at about the 200 yard mark.
There was a little tree set just on the other side of this gully which made a
good target for those inclined to use such aids while golfing. Most of the boys
had no trouble getting a good roll off the hill on the dry grass to make the
gully on their first try. 
There are those, who claim some people are natural golfers; there are others,
who claim boys simply put the golf ball down and hit it. Whatever it is, these
lads had no trouble getting around the course in fine order in spite of, or
because of, the limited number clubs carried by each.
Much to the boys surprise and delight, when they completed the ninth hole and
returned to the clubhouse for a drink of water, Mr. Young was most agreeable and
inquisitive about the success of their game. Each lad in turn explained how they
had enjoyed it and hoped to return some day for another round or two.
While Mr. Young addressed the boys, the men gathered in the clubhouse
drinking what looked like cold beer, smiled in agreement. Having young boys out
on the course in the hope of some day mastering the game was a good thing.
"Follow me, lads, I may have something for you." roared the Old
Man.
Not unlike the Pied Piper, the four boys followed along behind Mr. Young
pretty much single file in pecking order of the group, Bill Barker leading the
others, of course.
There was a garage to the right-hand side of the house and its double doors were just about even with where the house ended. Two concrete tracks lead
out to the street but it was obvious from the thick grass growing between this
garage was not used for parking a car.
When Mr. Young swung the doors open wide, even the boys could see no car had
seen the inside of this building in the past twenty-years. The floor and the
three walls were covered in golf clubs. Old clubs, new clubs, woods, irons,
putters; some clubs in bags some laying about. The walls had clubs hanging and
in bags-full from floor to ceiling. Some parts of the side and back walls, had
clubs stacked in three rows: one circling around the perimeter on the floor, one
row around the middle and another row up against the rafters at the top.
"O.K., now, you boys pick yourself out a set of clubs and a bag and when
you're done you bring them in for me to take a look at."
Wow. Was this the Old Man Young we had heard the terrible stories about? Must
have been since he is the only Mr. Young who's operating this golf course. The
boys were so happy and excited. Each boy rummaged through the mixture of steel
and wooden shafted clubs until they each had their own hand-picked set of golf
clubs.
Well, that was how golf started for at least four Doncaster District boys.
What more does a lad need than to be given a set of golf clubs at age eleven-years to get him interested in this wonderful activity?

Bill Barker and Billy Irvine became fast friends and continued to golf and
hang around the old house on Finlayson Road. There was no free lunch nor free
golf at Cedar Hill Golf Links. The two Bills had to hustle to make money to
cover the cost of their golfing so when the necessary funds were accumulated, it
was golf from sunup to sundown to get their monies' worth. Seventy-two holes a
day was played on a fairly regular basis during the summer when all the boys had
to do was find the money and golf. Green fees were 50 cents a day and 75 cents
on weekends.
It was late in the summer in 1948 when Mr. Young left and the new lessee
arrived, Lyle D. Barnes, with his wife, Leona and a one-year-old son, named Greg. It
wasn't long before Lyle noticed the two boys who were there regularly even after
the summer ended and they were back in school. There was always time for some
golf. When Lyle was lessee, he paid the property taxes and an additional $5500
per annum rent to the McRae family.
Before taking over as lessees of Cedar Hill Golf Course, Lyle and Leona's
address was list in the City of Victoria Directory as 424 Craigflower Rd. and
Lyle's occupation was listed as 'butcher', at Monterey Meat Market at the same
address. This business was presumably owned and operated by Lyle's father,
William H. Barnes (and mother, Rachel). Later on, in 1949, the father decided to
move his business to 2747 Oak Bay Ave., and on this occasion the services of one
Bill Barker and Billy Irvine were pressed into service to help Bill and Lyle
Barnes move and carry the many large freezer units into the new Oak Bay address.
When not golfing the course or helping with some maintenance chores, The two
Bill's were often asked to baby-sit Barnes-the-younger: Their only child:
Gregory. After spending so much time around the clubhouse, Billy was surprised
to learn that Lyle had a real passion for tennis. Lyle used to spend what little
free time he had, bouncing tennis balls off the side of the garage from the
paved area behind the house. Perhaps, this physical activity was a diversion
from anything related golf, although it should be mentioned, Lyle was an
excellent golfer and instructor.

Cedar Hill really came into being as a golf-course in 1921 when George McRae
was a young man of 21 years. His family had owned the property and it was still
a viable dairy farm business when is was agreed to lease part of the property
out to set up a nine-hole golf course. George was born in the McRae farmhouse
January 27, 1900, on land his father had cleared with the help of horses and
Japanese labourers.
The first lessee and professional was Eddie Eve and after him came a
gentleman named Robinson (but he didn't stay long) and then came Harry Young
about 1936.
Harry Warren Young was born in Dublin, Ireland and is credited with starting the
Cedar Hill Golf course as a viable business. He died in Victoria May 28, 1972. He
left his loving wife, Agnes, at the residence, 4030 Lockhaven Drv., It appears
the Youngs had no children.
check date ) Lyle Barnes was the lessee through 1951 when it became an
18-hole layout and operated by the Municipality of Saanich.

The Development of Cedar Hill Park - an essay in the 1976 Saanich Historical
Essay contest by a school student:
In 1966 the negotiations leading to the purchase of the McRae Estate by the
Saanich Municipality in 1967 began. After many months of negotiation, a price of
$1.2 million was decided upon for the remaining 132 acres (53.4 Hectares) of the
McCrae property. The following year the name of the property was officially
changed by Reeve, Hugh Curtis and Council, to Cedar Hill Park which still
included the golf course. The selling price was set by Victoria Law Courts after
a lengthy and expensive court battle; the judgment came down about $450,000 more
than Saanich had offered the McCraes for the 132.6 acres but only about
one-third of the McCraes' initial asking price. A capital spending budget
adopted by Saanich ratepayers in December 1965, set aside about $900,000 for the
deal, but Reeve Curtis announced the $1.2M price could be met. The Victoria Law
Courts' judgment also had Saanich paying the $70,000 legal costs. The McRae
family had owned this property since 1885.
Saanich Council decided in 1970 to make further improvements over the next
three-year to the golf course which included the building of a new clubhouse.
The complex we now know as Cedar Hill Recreation Centre is a Lester &
Peterson Architects' design and was built in 1972 at the exact location of the
McRea's old main cattle barn. Billy Irvine remembers helping his friend, Harvey
Amos, whose after-school job in 1947, was to remove the smelly debris generated
and deposited by the 120-plus cows the barn housed. The cattle barn was open at
both ends and its longitudinal axis, strangely enough, was followed exactly by
that of the newly constructed Cedar Hill Recreation Centre. (get True Heading)
The milk from these cows was delivered by horse-drawn cart to many Victoria
homes and supplied much of the Canadian Pacific Railway ships.
(confirm dates ca. 1970)
Also, it was decided at this time, that part of the McRae Estate lying on the
eastern side of Cedar Hill Road would be sold-off for townhouse development and
the northern boundary of the estate remain as natural park lands. Saanich
Planning Committee further recommended the sale of 10 acres (4 Hectares) to the
Greater Victoria School Board to be used for a new school and recreational park.
Other sections were sold for residential use; this included that part lying east
of the 5th and 18th fairways. This has made the present Cedar Hill Park property
significantly smaller than at the time of its purchase from the McRaes.
by Grant Soutar, Grade 6, Doncaster School. (get photo)

Dogwood Star, February 15, 1968 by A.W. (Bud) Mesher
see scan dogwoodstarmesher)
What Shall We Do With It?
Now what to do with it would seem to be the question of the day. Already we
are told portions of the land are to be or have been sold off for housing and an
additional ten acres is to used for school use. Presently, a large part of the
estate is taken up for gold course use which has been in existence for many
years which provides a monetary return to its owners of about $10,000 per year.
While supplying recreation for a small percentage of our residents, the golf
course can never be expected to justify the nearly 1,300,000 plus costs which
could well exceed another $200,000.
Therefore, it is plane to see some other use for the benefit of more people
must be found either in addition to golf course, or as an alternative. Whatever
the final use for the McCrae Estate will be, lets hope it will be the best sue
and for the benefit of all and worthy of the huge purchase price.
New Irrigation Watering System for Cedar Hill Golf Course - excepts from Norm
Gidney's Times-Colonist article April 3, 2004.
Starting in the winter of 2004, Cedar Hill Golf Course Manager, Gary Kelly,
announced Saanich would undertake a $2.1M dollar project to tap into the
underground water supply with the installation of an extensive irrigation system
the likes of which Cedar Hill Golf Course has never seen. So extensive is the
undertaking, says Kelly, it may take more than two-years to complete. Work will
be carried out mainly during the winter months when there is less golfer traffic
using the course.
The work, projected to be completed by the spring of 2006, coursed an
increase in green-fees to $38 per regular round and $23 per twilight round. A
full-privilege annual pass rises by $60 to $915. The use of well water will
permit the golf-course to be watered even when local watering restrictions are
usually implemented during the summer months. Holders of both full and partial
privilege annual passes generate an income of $530,000 per year for the Saanich
coffers. In 2003 Cedar Hill Golf Course earned a profit of $166,000 on more than
75,000 rounds of golf and is the only municipal recreational centre to operate
in the black.

Review, December 3, 1970
The action by Saanich to take over operation of Cedar Hill Golf Course was
spearheaded and supported by Alderman William (Sandy) Noel, himself an avid
golfer at Cedar Hill Golf Course. He was instrumental in seeing the course
continue as an 18 hole venue when the voices of many were calling for its
reduction back to a nine-hole course. A new course layout was implement which
saw fairway13 become fairway No.1 enabling players to start their game just
below the new clubhouse.
(get layout of course from various years)
Bill Goldsworthy became pro at Cedar Hill Golf Course in June 1965 when the
green-fees were $2.50 for weekdays and $3 for weekends. Assistant pro was Jimmy
Girard. Four-and-a-half years later a new $36,000 clubhouse was opened beside
what is now the (check 1970 layout) green. It housed a coffee-shop, run by
Marion Longmoore, a members' lounge and a storage area for members' clubs. The
pro shop was used a separate building. The new clubhouse building was designed
by Wagg & Hambleton and constructed by Bird Construction Co. Ltd..

Review April 30, 1970
The Development Plan for Cedar Hill Park was before Saanich Special
Committee, Monday evening, April 27, 1970. It was agreed the Cedar Hill Golf
Course would be operated by the municipality starting in January 1971. Alderman
Sandy Noel presented a strong case against using land north of the Tattersall
extension for park use. He argued it would not be possible to build the class
of golf course Saanich residents deserved if this meant, " chopping off the
sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth holes." He continued his argument by
reminding councilors Cedar Hill Golf Course is the only Saanich recreational
facility which generates a profit and would amortize its cost of $1.2M over a
twenty-five year period.
Various points of view, including hiring or not hiring a professional golf
course architect were bandied about by Alderman Bill Campbell; Ald. Foster
Isherwood; Ald. Ald. Les Passmore and Ald. Mrs. Gunning. It would appear from
viewing comment recorded in council minutes, it was Ald. Mrs. Gunning who
processed the most vision regarding the future use of Cedar Hill Park. Another
recommendation from this meeting was that the southwest corner of the property
be used to build a recreational centre.

Gordon Head News Vol.2 No.31 August 12-18 1987 (reference only, written by
Bill Irvine 2006)
Moving Third Tee No Fair Way to Settle Problem, Golfers Say
During the many 1987 Saanich council meetings, the problem of errant gold-balls hitting newly constructed houses along the
eastern side of the third
fairway was discussed ad infinitum.
Some Saanich Council meetings were very
heated. The upshot of the whole thing was to build a large, netted fence along
the fairway's edge and in front of the many homes. For the golfers -- who
claimed the golf-course predated the housing by decades -- this was a better
solution than having the long par-5 shortened, as the many homeowners supported.
One council meeting was attended by so many interested parties, the chamber and
hallways were filled to overflowing with the remainder outside filling the
entire Saanich Municipal Hall stairway all the way down to the parking lot. The
council proceedings were piped outside by loudspeakers.
Mayor Howard Sturrock was in attendance with Ald.
John Mika in the chair.
Ald. Coell, commented he had never seen such an emotionally charged group as the
one before him that evening. Speaker after speaker rose to the centre-floor
microphone to express their chagrin at whatever solution was proposed. Many
homeowners were booed off the floor by the unsettling crowd. One woman mentioned
she was not only a Cedar Hill Golf Course homeowner but also a member at Uplands
Golf Course and the crowd assembled got the distinct impression she frankly
couldn't give a damn about the golfers at Cedar Hill Golf Course. She was drummed
off the floor with the resounding taunts of, "Well. hoyty-toyty!" It
was not a pleasant scene.
Mayor Sturrock, who for the most part remained silent, sitting on the
sidelines of the council assembly, was visibly very upset by these proceedings
and was not in anyway encouraged by calls from some of those assembled yelling:
"Block for mayor, 'Block for mayor!: A resounding reference to the
favourable support the users of Cedar Hill Golf Course were receiving from Ald.
Irennie Block. Many there that evening were convinced if someone had thrown a
rope into the mix, there would have been a lynching for sure.

== 1993 --
Council passed a new fee schedule for Cedar Hill Golf Course at the November
29, 1993, meeting. Regular green fees will increase to $22 while twilight will
rise to $18 starting in January 1994. A full-privilege, annual pass will cost
$600. The prime-time pass restrictions implemented in 1993 will continue in the
hope the resulting increased revenues will be sustained.

== 1994 ==
T-C Where You Live - Jeff Bell
Old Driving Range Remains Empty
Way to improve the use of the driving range beside teh 10th fairway are being
discussed, said Mayor Frank Leonard.
January 21, 1999 - Jeff Bell T-C
Decision near to use driving range for short-game only practice.

May 13, 1996 Clubhouse Burns Down T-C May 14 (written by Bill Irvine)
An early Monday morning arson attack on Cedar Hill Golf Course's clubhouse
destroyed much of it. The alarm came into Saanich fire Department, Monday at
12:22 a.m.. The tragedy couldn't have come at a worse time with the Cedar Hill
Open Tournament scheduled for this weekend. Damage is estimated at $550,000
which includes the destruction of the new $32,000 roof. The pro shop, housed in
a separate building, was not damaged. Club President, Stan Gibb, stated the
Cedar Hill Open Tournament would go ahead as planned with a few innovations
incorporating the use of the Cedar Hill Rec Centre and the Pro-shop. The
25-year-old building (completed 1971) is insured for 750,000 for the building
and loss-of-business stated the Municipal Administrator, Bob Sharp. "It is
literally the hangout for hundreds of people," stated Keith Barwick, course
manager. Every day sees 300-400 golfers on the course playing a total of 90,000
rounds per year. Saanich Fire Capt. Ron Cullis, says they are investigating
other suspicious fires set in the area the same evening and two youths were
apprehended for questioning by police already. The investigation is continuing.
Councillor, Bob Gillespie noted that once the insurance adjusters have filed
their findings the decision to rebuild or start anew will be made. A new
clubhouse would costs about $2 million he said. At a subsequent Saanich council
meeting in September it was decided to build a new clubhouse at an estimated
cost of $1.3 million. The new structure would be self contained unit with
pro-shop, lounge, meeting rooms and restaurant to better serve its users and
generate more income for Saanich. Projections indicate present profits of
$124,000 per year could increase to $500,000 once the new facility is
up-and-running, stated Park & Recreation Director, Don Hunter.

Times Colonist August 22, 1998
Top Junior Title Goes to Cedar Hill Golfer
Gordie Scutt won the Canadian Junior and Juvenile Golf Championship, Friday,
August 21, 1998 held at Levis, PQ. Scutt who learned as a junior at Cedar Hill
Golf Course, carded and impressive one-under par 287 over the four-round event.
Gordie will be taking up residency in September at the University of Washington
on a golf scholarship.

Wednesday, September 6, 2000 Saanich News p.21
Matt LeBlanc returned to the site of his 1999 Cedar Hill Junior Club
championship triumph in fine style August 21 to 24 narrowly defeating Adam
Sullivan by two strokes to take the 2000 title. LeBlanc carded a 272 which
included a hole-in-one at the 15th par three.
Bibliography:
Mrs. Violet (nee Eve) Seaton
101-710 Lampson St.
Victoria, BC V9A 6A6
Cherie Barthwick
Fairburn Elementary School
Grade 5 Div. 10
This page was last updated on 09/13/11.
